It was a grand experiment putting cameras in the middle of a group of people and recording their every fart for 72 hours, editing it down to 18 minutes of concentrated reality and then selling it to the networks. It was also an incredible way to cut costs on talent, with no paychecks being cut for actors or writers. Despite someone coming up with an even less expensive form of entertainment, called YouTube, we must accept that reality TV is here to stay.
Producers embraced the formula of following people around with cameras and sound guys and hoping like hell that something interesting happened. Show creators who were early to the party had their pick of fun and exciting groups of people to film, and shows like “COPS” and “The Deadliest Catch” were TV gold. After all, there was no shortage of action on crab boats or police cars. The key for these reality pioneers was to follow the right crab boats and the right cops. It turns out that fishing 150 miles off the coast of Alaska is a whole lot more exciting to watch than some guy with a crab trap full of chicken necks trying his luck off of a railroad bridge outside of Mahahawkin, NJ. Similarly, it was a good idea to film COPS episodes in trailer parks and housing projects where bare-chested men with home made tattoos were more likely to be having slap fights with their common-law wives. It was no coincidence that COPS never spent much time doing ride-alongs in affluent suburbs – there’s a paucity of toothless meth addicts and street corner drug dealers to chase in places like Reston, Virginia.
Anything this successful in the world of entertainment is going to be done ad nauseum. We’ve watched like well-trained zombies as camera crews followed exterminators, gold miners, homicide detectives, Kardashians, wedding gown salesmen, cake decorators and God knows who else. My TV won’t stop telling me about the exciting shows coming up where we’ll soon be privy to the behind the scenes drama of rodeo girls. Rodeo girls?! You make the popcorn and I’ll get the barbiturates!
As we can see from shows like “Rodeo Girls”, show developers are constantly searching for people in or on the fringe to thrust into reality stardom. One enterprising group of show developers at A&E happened upon a diamond in the rough in rural Louisiana; a financially successful family of country folk. It was like the Beverly Hillbillies with no Milburn Drysdale and a few extra Jethro Bodines. A ton of episodes later, “Duck Dynasty” has turned into a major franchise in reality TV.
In recent weeks, videos have surfaced of Duck Dynasty’s Phil Robertson, (he’s the one in the camo tux) saying all kinds of politically incorrect things. Phil’s topics have included such hot topics as gay bashing and his belief that homosexuality leads to bestiality, some racial insensitivity and most recently, suggesting that men marry 15 year old girls. As one might expect, people are up in arms. The network is struggling to deal with a bearded goose which has suddenly started laying exploding eggs.
For all our clamoring for reality shows featuring eccentric oddballs, there is a discomfort when these characters turn out to be a little too authentic. It appears that as much as the viewing public enjoys reality TV, we simply don’t want too much reality. Anyone with half a brain* will accept that there are those among us with unique views on race, just as there are those with homophobic ideologies or a taste for the younger versions of young ladies. While it’s desirable to watch as reality stars live the bumpkin dream of making a small fortune by successfully selling duck calls, we just don’t want to know if they may actually embrace some of the politically incorrect views we’d typically expect to find in the backwater locales of some of our redder states**.
For anyone who’s interested, I’ve got a great idea for a new reality TV series. Cameras will follow around a bunch of A&E executives and producers as they try to figure out how to solve the problems posed by the rants of one of their reality TV superstars. We’ll be glued to our flat screens as spin doctors in Armani suits try to minimize the damage of one of Phil’s outrageous comments, only to have another gem surface a few hours later! The gritty drama interspersed with zany hi-jinx will make for Emmy-worthy entertainment.
As is always the case when I blog about possible formats for new reality shows, I offer this concept free of charge, asking only that my name and blogs are featured in the show credits. Also, I should get one of those Emmy’s***.
* In the spirit of correctness with which I’ve got to write if I ever hope to be employed by A&E, I’d like to point out that having half a brain is a difficult handicap physical challenge and people who live life with such a disability should be applauded and not confused with the common phrase of ones having “half a brain” or the similar label of being a “half wit”. In the event that a network decides to base a new reality show on the adventures of a group of people struggling to live with only partial brains, please leave me out of it. Besides, it’s been done already – witness any episode of “Jersey Shore”?
** People with politically incorrect ideas can be found in any corner of the United States of America, and indeed anywhere in the world. The author’s use of red states as a qualifier is not meant to imply that residents of said states harbor any such aberrant values; It was simply a ploy used to make residents of blue states feel even more superior than usual. This description was also not meant to convey any bias toward color-blind readers.
*** I don’t want to come off as a profiteer, but my altruism only runs so deep. Screw the Emmy and give me some cold, hard cash.
Reblogged this on 1pointperspective.
LikeLike
Great post!
Trashy reality tv is probably one of my greatest guilty pleasures so I feel somewhat partially to blame for the epidemic, haha!
LikeLike
I’m considering following you around with a camera while you watch other people being followed around with cameras. You’re gonna be a star, kid! Just act natural…just not too natural.
LikeLike
Haha! Nothing can beat a bit of scripted reality!
LikeLike
Let’s try that again people. Pinkjumpers, try to look more surprised when you click on the blog link this time and Phil, you just stay quiet this time….andddd…Action!
LikeLike
Keep your eyes open for my new reality show. “The Napping.”
LikeLike
I saw the pilot. I LOVED the part when you rolled over and farted!
LikeLike
Why thank you! Every time I pass gas, Taco Bell sells a chalupa.
LikeLike
What a beautiful sentiment…I just cried a little
LikeLike
Yes. I would say cold hard cash is in order. Good ideas should come at a price.
LikeLike
I am still in a state of disbelief that none of the major cable networks have scooped up any of my original ideas from the first post. There’s a lack of appreciation for my genius.
LikeLike
There really is! Having worked in the industry for years I can honestly tell you a lot worse ideas came across my desk and some of them made it to air.
LikeLike
Personally, I had high hopes someone would pick up “America’s Next Top Mortician” – it had all the earmarks of a stone cold hit.
LikeLike
Brilliant!
LikeLike
Click on the link in the post, there’s more where that came from!
LikeLike
Now that would be a reality show I would watch
LikeLike
I find that watching my own life and pretending it’s a reality show is very enjoyable. I particularly enjoy the commercial breaks, which give me time to step back and figure out how to get myself out of the latest pickle.
LikeLike
That duck programme is not on over here but if that is what the guy thinks and people don’t like it well then switch off and look at coke and burger ads on another channel
LikeLike
People like their reality stars to be quirky, but politically correct quirky…I honestly don’t see how anyone could be surprised that someone who never aspired to TV stardom could harbor opinions which don’t jibe with the socially accepted norms. Then again, I don’t know understand the appeal of watching hill folk scampering around in the woods either.
LikeLike
Is that what it is? If they want to pay me to film me wiping my arse I am open to negotiation
LikeLike
Umm…I hate to break the news to you, but they already have filmed you doing that. Despite a significant amount of digitizing, true Gingerfightback fans are able to tell it’s you by the stylish wrist work you employ for even the most personal or mundane tasks.
LikeLike
That’s why my toilet roll is permanently pixelated!
LikeLike
If I had a tv, I might watch your shows. Before a month ago, i didn’t even know what “Duck Dynasty” was.
LikeLike
Sorry. I would’ve replied to your comment sooner, but I was busy watching TV.
LikeLike
Np. We do what we gotta do.
LikeLike
Cmon man! It’s wild card Saturday in the NFL!
LikeLike
Hellz yeah! With more today!
LikeLike
I’ve always wanted to start a reality show about myself running auditions for the next great reality show.
LikeLike
Depending upon how you run your auditions, that could be great!
LikeLike
I would be glued to my set watching a show that revealed how these shows get created. I want to see the faces of the people who thought something like “Rodeo Girls” would be a good idea and I really, really want to hear what didn’t make the cut…now that’s entertainment.
LikeLike
Although I’m sure it would be very entertaining, it would never make the air. No show where executives and creative consiultants sit and discuss what idiots the viewing public must be could ever see the light of day.
LikeLike
That is crap I’ll watch dammit! This fascinates me trying to figure out why and how they choose these shows. I’d also love to see the guy who decides these are fantastic ideas and sends more people out with cameras and boom equipment
LikeLike
It’s hard for me not to poke fun at reality TV. Every time I feel like giving it a rest, a new show pops up. I was watching a donut making competition show last night. It was all I could do to keep from dropping myself in a vat of hot oil then rolling around in confectioners sugar.
LikeLike
Are you trying to drive the ladies crazy, or what?
–you–hot oil–sugar–
You’re like a Krispy Kreme commercial on a soft porn channel.
Did I go too far? Of course.
*grin*
LikeLike
All that and zero calories (unless you count my sugary coating)
LikeLike
You’re definitely ALL that…and a bag of chips.
LikeLike
On another topic, it appeared the frozen weather followed you all the way to Georgia. Have the citizens of Atlanta politely asked you and hubby to please take your polar vortex and beat a hasty path back to the land of the Canooks?
LikeLike
I have a signed note saying it is not our fault.
But just in case, we’re not leaving the condo for fear people will recognize we hail from the frozen tundra.
I sit on the balcony in my fur-lined bikini, drinking hot toddys and cursing the weather gods.
LikeLike
I hear it’s in the 70’s back at the bungalow.
LikeLike
Now that’s cold.
But I forgive you.
You live in New Jersey.
LikeLike
Not everyone in my state is so easily forgiven.
LikeLike
I think I speak for everyone when I say that fur-lined bikinis are HOT!
LikeLike
Jalapeño hot.
LikeLike
I think your pitch is fantastic. Sublime. The only possible tweak I can recommend is that the A&E Executive show is combined with Deadliest Catch. We could call it, “Things Without Backbones.”
LikeLike
I can’t wait till the episode when the creative consultant with the Harvard business degree gets his foot tangled in the rope and the giant crab pot pulls him into the icy waters.
LikeLike
I’d watch that reality show about the A&E attorneys for sure. You deserve cash AND and Emmy for this idea, Dave.
LikeLike
Thanks Peg! True genius like ours is seldom recognized though…we’ll just have to get our entertainment here in blog-land.
LikeLike
So true. We probably won’t be fully appreciated until we’re dead.
LikeLike
…and what good is that?!
LikeLike
…and what good is that?!
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Blogdramedy and commented:
I’ve had a bit too much of the cold variety of reality. The 2013 ice storm is still kicking my butt with intermittent power outages and NO INTERNET SERVICE! Reading Dave’s post about reality tv shows has brought it all into “perspective.” Thanks Dave!
LikeLike
I am so not a reality show fan … that stuff drives me crazy all the Housewife and Kardashian crapola dude. I could live without that, you know there is even a show called Amish Mafia? Dude I had no idea it had gone to these extremes and that people continue to watch.Apparently there’s still something called Big Brother. Dude Cut it out already. But the only show that I did like watching was the Alaska crab fishermen Deadliest Catch … I thought that was kind of cool for a couple of seasons until one of the main dudes died. But if your show ever comes on the air, I’d totally watch it.
LikeLike
I don’t see how the network executives can ignore this groundswell of support….I’m expecting a call any day now.
LikeLike
Reality TV should never be too realistic. Rookie error
LikeLike
I know, right? They should hire some of those actors and actresses from Survivor and put fake beards on them.
LikeLike
I wonder who writes the scripts for reality TV.
I lose brain cells every time they’re on, and because I didn’t smoke pot in college, I still have several dozen to protect valiantly.
“Next Great Baker” just makes me hungry and forces upon me at least two more crushes I don’t have time for. Thanks, Cake Boss.
LikeLike
There are scripts? If so, those shows are even worse than I thought!
LikeLike
Shocking! Every last person hasn’t been indoctrinated into the PC cult.
Oh well, I can sleep better at night knowing that the powers that be are working tirelessly to correct that so that someday all cultures and beliefs people have in this world will eventually merge into one neutral and inert miasma.
Won’t the world be a fascinating place then!
LikeLike
I’m not looking forward to having Jon Stewart anchoring FoxNews. Where’s the fun in that?
LikeLike
Annoying is what it would be, and even more biased than usual (assuming that’s even possible).
LikeLike